Certification Comparison

Certification Comparison

Comparing IPMA®, PMI® and Prince2® certifications

Certification Comparison

IPMA®, PMI® and Prince2®

We receive many calls from individuals regarding the different certification accreditations that are available in the market place. When you apply for a project manager job opening, there is always the chance that the company may not consider your application if you do not possess project management certification.

This of course raises the question as to which project management accreditation the recruiting company or HR manager prefers.

Organisation managers and learning and development specialists are looking for a global certification that has a firm foundation in the factors that lead to project and business success. Our experience is that, very often there is a distinct lack of understanding by those hiring as to the relative merits of the credentials that are most commonly considered.

Project management certification comparison

The main products in the market-place, and how they compare based on three specific criteria, are shown in the above image.

The three criteria for comparison are:

Prerequisites
Breadth of Coverage
Rigour of Assessment

When trying to determine which certification is best for your requirements, talk to a reputable organisation that understands the difference between the options available - Invest wisely!

Prerequisites

Prerequisites help assure that a certification is targeted at the right person. For this criterion, we apply the work of Dr Paul D. Giammalvo who has written extensively on the topic. Paul based his analysis on two key information points:

A Professional Engineer (PE in the USA) credential using it as a standard for comparison, and
Malcolm Gladwell’s 10,000 hour threshold for mastery

Breadth of Coverage

What practice base does the certification cover? Is it a

Methodology like PRINCE2
Knowledge Taxonomy like PMBOK®V5 (PMI)
Competence Framework like IPMA Competence Baseline

Rigour of Assessment

Many people can prepare for an exam, take it within two weeks, and pass. Better evidence of true grasp is to present a portfolio of evidence that documents that you have delivered results in each item or element under assessment. Using these criteria to define the three faces of “Certification Effectiveness” we represent the results as shown in Table 1 by cross-multiplying:

Prerequisites % xBreadth of Coverage % xRigour of Assessment %;

Certification

Prerequisite Score

Breadth Score

Rigour Score

Certification Effectiveness

IPMA Level A®

IPMA Level B®

IPMA Level C®

IPMA Level D®

PMI PMP®

PMI CAPM®

PRINCE2® Practitioner

N/A

PRINCE2® Foundation

N/A

This article is a synopsis of a paper published by Stacy Goff, president of ASAPM (American Society for the Advancement of Project Management) www.asapm.org